Mister Bottom's Folly
Some Scribbles and Such
Friday, 17 January 2025
ZELENSKY ATTENDS DECEMBER EU MEETING
This summary is not available. Please
click here to view the post.
Wednesday, 15 January 2025
NoW UPDATE: GAZA: GOING…GOING…GONE!
IT’S HARD TO IMAGINE it’s been fifteen months since that fateful day in
October 2023 when Hamas launched its attack beyond the fence separating the
Palestinian enclave of Gaza and Israel. Hundreds of civilians and IDF soldiers were
killed or kidnapped in the lightning assault by Hamas fighters. It was a
murderous, criminal action, no doubt, and it shocked Israeli society to its
core. But there are questions that need answering: Was the Hamas attack
unprovoked? Was it unexpected? And was Israel’s subsequent response in Gaza a
proportionate one, and in keeping with international law and humanitarian codes of
conduct? And I think it is fair to say that the answer to all three questions is
no, no and no.
IN THE WAKE of October 7, former Israeli defense minister, Yoav Gallant said:
“I
have ordered a complete siege on the Gaza Strip. There will be no electricity,
no food, no fuel, everything is closed. We are fighting human animals, and we
are acting accordingly.”
IT is to be expected that emotions ran high following October 7, and intemperate
speech and expressions of anger and outrage are understandable. But when such
statements are made by a cabinet minister in charge of directing Israel’s military
response to the Hamas attack, such statements are troubling. Furthermore, expressions
like Gallant’s, and worse, are shared repeatedly—to this day—by most of
Israel’s government and a considerable majority of its citizenry. Unfortunately,
these statements have been matched by actions carried out by the Israeli
military forces. Since last fall, the IDF (Israeli Defense Force) has conducted
a relentless siege on the Palestinian enclave resulting in the destruction of virtually
the entire Gaza Strip and the displacement of 90% of Palestinians from their
homes. Over one million Gazans have been forced to move to the southern part of
the Strip with minimal food, water and medical services available. The
twenty-five mile long by five-mile-wide Gaza Strip was called the “world’s
largest open-air prison” by Britain’s then-PM David Cameron on a visit in 2010.
Even before Israel began its ethnic cleansing campaign of the northern third of
the enclave, the Gaza Strip was considered to be the most densely populated
region on earth. Now, most of its citizens are further crowded into refugee
camps in the south, with inadequate infrastructure and services, their lives in
limbo, their homes and communities razed to the ground, and where they are
subjected to daily bombings by Israeli Air Force jets and drones and IDF ground
forces who justify their actions by saying they are targeting Hamas fighters embedded in the Gaza population.
ICJ Court at The Hague, Netherlands |
Fun times in the Levant….
PALESTINIAN DEATHS due to direct military actions by Israel and its deliberately
withholding the necessities of life (food, water, medicines and shelter) are
estimated to be upwards of 50,000 with three times as many injured and sick due
to the horrific conditions in the enclave and the near complete destruction of
its residences, businesses, farmlands and critical infrastructure (including
hospitals). It should be noted that this death toll may be a gross underestimate because it is based on statistics compiled
by the Gazan Health Authority for hospital deaths only. There may be three
times as many dead under the rubble, their remains never to be recovered.
Some put the death toll closer to 200,000, a genocide by anyone’s
definition. Including Amnesty International which said in its recent report:
“Our research
reveals that, for months, Israel has persisted in committing genocidal acts,
fully aware of the irreparable harm it was inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza.
It continued to do so in defiance of countless warnings about the catastrophic
humanitarian situation and of legally binding decisions from the International
Court of Justice (ICJ) ordering Israel to take immediate measures to
enable the provision of humanitarian assistance to civilians in Gaza.”—Agnès
Callamard, Secretary General of Amnesty International.
👉SO, was the 10/7 attack by Hamas unprovoked, a shot out of the blue, without
rhyme nor reason? The true history of the Palestinian people since WWII says
otherwise. Israelis, since the inception of the state1 in 1948, have
worked to confiscate Palestinian lands and properties, using the courts as well
as by force and violence. Contrary to popular opinion, the land was not
‘uninhabited’ and free for the taking after the war. It wasn’t “a land without
people for a people without a land.” It was inhabited by Arabs, but also
Christians, Jews and other minorities who got along well enough when Palestine
was considered “a multi-ethnic and multi-cultural society."
In 1945, Arabs were the majority, over 63% of the population, with Jews at
around 30%. Jewish immigration from Europe increased dramatically in the
wake of Nazi armies, and afterwards in the exodus of survivors of the European Holocaust
who came to see Palestine as the only safe place that would have them. And they
had a point if we recall the less-than-warm welcome most nations gave Jewish
emigrants before, during the war, and afterwards.
Nevertheless, ever since 1948’s Nakba, or
“Catastrophe”, where over 600,000 Palestinians were forced from their homes, either
fleeing the country or settling in other regions (like Gaza), Israel’s goal has
been the expulsion of all Palestinians from lands many Israelis believe were
gifted to them by God. Through wars, legal chicanery, violence and outright murder,
they continued to ethnically cleanse the country until October 2023 when Gazans
once more rebelled, this time dealing Israel a significant blow. But the Hamas
attack also gave Israel the excuse to eradicate, once and for all, the people
of Gaza by any means necessary, up to and including ethnic cleansing and
genocide. In doing so, Israel has become a pariah state in the eyes of the
world, except for the United States and its Western cucks followers.
Gaza and the West Bank are considered occupied territory according to the
United Nations and Israel, as an “occupying force”, has no right of self-defense
to justify its actions in Gaza. In addition, Gazans and Palestinians in the
West Bank and East Jerusalem are an “occupied people” and as such have rights
under international law to take up arms against their occupiers.
So, no, the 10/7 attack on kibbutzim and
military outposts by Hamas was not ‘unprovoked’. As terrible and bloody as it
was, it nevertheless was born out of decades of disenfranchisement,
settler violence and apartheid rule. Given
the same circumstances, would we not take up arms against our oppressor and
fight for our rights, like the Palestinians?
👉WAS 10/7 unexpected? Attacks into Israel—be it car bombs, suicide
bombers, missiles and what have you, have long been a feature in the
relationship between Palestine and Israel. While Israel had a modern military
with an air force, navy etc., Palestinians had to rely on homemade bombs and
missiles and smuggled guns and munitions. It was always an asymmetric warfare conducted
between the two. But after Israeli settlers left the Gaza Strip in 2005 and Hamas
came to power in 2006 elections, the dynamics changed as Hamas, a political
party, developed a militia that could challenge Israel’s IDF using guerrilla
warfare tactics. Israel, for its part would periodically “mow the grass” in Gaza, meaning it would use its air
power, missiles and artillery to destroy parts of the Strip where militias were
said to be found. But these ‘overkill’ operations by Israel were really meant
to cow the Gazan population into submission. This was the pattern of aggression
between Palestinians and Israelis until October 2023.
THERE IS INTERESTING speculation that suggests the Israeli government
had prior knowledge of the 10/7 attack and chose to let it happen in order to
give free rein to the Israeli military to render Gaza uninhabitable and its population
immiserated and amenable to forced emigration. Whether Israel knew of the impending
attack or not, they knew Palestinians would attack at some point because they have
been left with no alternative other than armed resistance. Israel may not have
known about the 10/7 attack specifically, but they did know that another attack
from the “occupied people” of Gaza against their “occupiers” was inevitable.
No, 10/7 was not unexpected. It just upped the ante on the ‘business as
usual’ conflict between Israelis and Palestinians.
👉AS FOR WHETHER THE ACTIONS taken by Israel in Gaza (and increasingly the
West Bank) were proportionate and in keeping with international laws and
standards of war, I think after more than fifteen months of horrific siege warfare
the evidence is in to suggest they were disproportionate and criminal under
international law.
“Ethnic cleansing”, “genocide”, “war crimes” are words bandied about a bit too freely these days but, in this case, they are words the state of
Israel must wear around its neck like a reeking albatross.2
Cheers, Jake. ____________________________________
* Recently, Brazilian authorities launched an
investigation into a vacationing IDF soldier’s activities in Gaza and whether
they constituted war crimes. The Israeli consulate in Brazil [Brazil is a
signatory of the ‘Rome Statutes”. Ed.] had to spirit the soldier out of the country pronto.
We may see more such investigations in the future as countries around the world honour the ICC’s arrest
warrants against traveling Israeli military and political leaders who are deemed culpable
in committing war crimes, including genocide, in Gaza.
1. For some time now, Israel has been seen by many to be an apartheid
state as described in a February 2022 report by Amnesty
International because of its treatment of Palestinians who live in the
occupied territories (Gaza, West Bank, East Jerusalem) and for those Palestinian-Israelis living within Israel proper who are treated as second-class citizens, lacking
the same roster of rights as Jewish-Israelis. The apartheid label has become even more
relevant and descriptive following Israel’s genocidal actions in Gaza.
2. For the record, I predict that in six months we will not hear a peep
on the news about “Gaza”. Other ‘stuff’ will be foremost in our brains by then,
I’m afraid.
IF THE WORLD community can watch a genocide happening in real time on billions
of cell phones AND DO NOTHING to stop it, I think Israel will get away with
(mass) murder. Most Palestinians left inside Israel, especially those from the occupied lands, will leave and become part of
the diaspora and disappear from the headlines. Those who are left will either die or submit to a life under an apartheid regime. I hope I am wrong, very wrong, about this....
THE OTHER DAY retired American Colonel Lawrence Wilkerson, commented on the lack of a global response to the genocide happening daily before our eyes in Gaza. He suggests we
have become “accustomed to bestiality”. By this he meant we have become habituated
into accepting more and more intense levels of violence, criminality and depravity as features (and not faults) of our
modern age. He may be right.
Labels:
Being Human,
Death,
hubris,
Human Nature,
Modernity,
politics,
sin,
violence,
war
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)