THERE’S A COURT CASE in the news in recent days involving that oldie
but goodie MK-ULTRA program. In the lawsuit, the two plaintiffs, Julie Tanny and Lana Ponting, represent
“affected patients and families who suffered lifelong psychological and
cognitive damage”, and are suing the Royal Victoria Hospital (RVC), McGill
University and the Government of Canada for compensatory damages they and their
families suffered while they were patients at the Allan Memorial Institute
which was associated with McGill and RVC during their time there. The 'studies' at the Allan came to be known as the “Montreal Experiments”. Dr. Donald Ewan Cameron headed
the research team that explored the treatment of schizophrenia using what he
called “psychic forcing”. His regime included long-term, drug induced comas,
intensive electroconvulsive therapy sessions (ECT), repeated audio messages, sometimes hundreds of thousands of times (the “psychic forcing” portion of the treatments), and various drug therapies
including LSD, then a new and little understood chemical compound.
Cameron
hoped to “deprogram” his patients*, to erase certain personality traits he
deemed responsible for their debilitation, and to add “positive”,
self-reinforcing ones in their place. With his system of “depatterning”, that
is, destabilizing and disordering patients’ memories and sense of self, and,
through “psychic forcing”, he hoped to install a new and better personality, free from
thoughts and emotions that led patients to seek treatment in the first place.
Cameron’s therapies did a good job deconstructing his patient’s personalities. It was a tad less successful in implanting functional, normative ones in their
place.
“Cameron believed that mental illness was a consequence of an individual having learned “incorrect” ways of responding to the world. These “learned responses” created “brain pathways” that led to repetitive abnormal behaviour.
He wanted to “de-pattern” patients’ minds with the application of highly disruptive electroshock twice a day, as opposed to the norm of three times a week. According to him, this would break all incorrect brain pathways, thus de-patterning the mind. Some call it brainwashing.” (McGill)
👉TODAY, we view
such practices as illegal and morally reprehensible, and akin to torture. I go
into more detail about Cameron and the “Montreal Experiments” here, so I’ll just mention the good doctor’s theories,
developed and published during WWII and after, came to the attention of the
newly formed Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) in the United States that sought
to understand how to scientifically interrogate enemy spies and successfully
break down their resistance during questioning.
👉IT’S IMPORTANT
TO NOTE that, during the Korean War in the early 1950s, some American POWs
signed statements or filmed interviews condemning America and in other ways cooperated with North Korean and Chinese forces, giving rise to the
“brainwashed” theory that American POWs must have had their minds manipulated by
their captors; how else to explain their treasonous behaviour. [Hunger, extreme
physical and psychological abuse, and cooperating as a strategy to stay alive
were the real causes of POWs' manufactured disloyalty, not ‘brainwashing’. Ed.]
Many returning POWs who had cooperated with the enemy were treated with disdain
by military authorities; some were investigated and court-martialled. The CIA
wanted to know more about brainwashing—whether it was a feasible method of
information extraction and if it could be used to change personalities, even to
change a person’s allegiances and becoming unwitting ‘double
agents’ for the Americans. To study the matter, the CIA initiated a
program called MK-ULTRA that had numerous test sites and sub-programs in the United States that analyzed the effects of, say, dosing unknowing citizens with LSD and observing their
behaviour while under the influence of the drug. Other drugs like heroin and
mescaline were used in the covert and illegal program of testing unsuspecting
US citizens.1 Sensory deprivation, hypnosis, ECT, psychological
torture were used on hundreds of unsuspecting American citizens. Hospitals,
universities, research institutes, and prisons became part of the program, harvesting test subjects from vulnerable populations, which was phased out by the late 1960s, though some suggest aspects of the
covert operation continued.
In 1975 the US Congressional Church Committee held
hearings reviewing the workings of the CIA, including the MK-ULTRA program.
When the committee asked for the files pertaining to the top-secret program,
they were informed all the records had been destroyed in 1973 by the outgoing CIA
Director, Richard Helms. (Oops! My bad.😆)
![]() |
| Abu Ghraib prison, Iraq. circa 2009 |
IT'S FAIR TO SAY that patients and persons left behind in their wake led somewhat less rosy lives in the years following their treatment at the hands of Gottlieb and Cameron.
IN CANADA, the
“Montreal Experiments” led by Doctor Cameron and funded, in part, by a foreign
intelligence service, the CIA, since the late 1950s, has not had the public
exposure of MK-ULTRA, with congressional hearings and high-profile lawsuits in the US. But, in 2019 there was a a bit of a stir when survivors of the Allan Institute brought forward
a class action lawsuit against RVC, McGill University, the Canadian government,
and the American government, though ultimately their suit could NOT include the
American government because the US had an “Absolute Sovereign Immunity” agreement with
Canada between the 1940s-60s with Canadian common law granting foreign states immunity
from lawsuits stemming from Canadian courts. So, the US got a get-out-of-jail-free card from Canada. [I hope that went both ways! Ed.] That changed in 1982 with Canadian
law allowing exceptions to cross-border lawsuits where bodily injury is
sustained. Unfortunately, the court ruled in the 2019 class action that there
could be no retroactive venue for lawsuits to include the US government because their actions (in the CIA’s case, partially funding Cameron’s
experiments) had occurred during the immunity period. Nice.
AT THE MOMENT, the
2019 class action lawsuit allows only the families of survivors to sue RVH,
McGill University and the Canadian government for compensation, because, in 1992,
the federal government established a program, “The Allan Memorial Institute
Depatterned Persons Assistance Plan” to deal with lawsuits filed at the time by sevety-seven former inmates patients. Each patient was paid $100,000, signing waivers against any future
lawsuits.
👍However, in the 2019 class action, along with their families, patients
can sue McGill University for compensation; the Allan Memorial Institute is
on the McGill University campus.
👍Descendants and family members, and additional patients left out of the 1992 settlement (around 300
people) can sue all three.
A FINAL NOTE: Earlier
this year, Quebec’s Superior Court denied Royal Victoria Hospital’s appeal to
be exempted from the lawsuit. So, the last of the legal hurdles is over and a
trial date should be established sometime next year. Yes, the wheels of justice
turn very, very slow!
CHEERS, JAKE. _____________________________________
* Test subjects or guinea
pigs is a better description of dozens of patients who went to the Allan
for treatment of mild depression or other ailments and emerged broken with
cognitive disabilities and personalities forever changed. I recall reading
about one man who went there for treatment of an acute pain in his jaw, his
symptoms suggesting he suffered from what today is called “trigeminal neuralgia”, something I’ve had
firsthand experience with for over twenty years. Today TGN is treated using a variety of
medications. Back then, I assume it was considered psychosomatic and not an
organic neurological condition because no discernable cause could then be discovered, and doctors had only patients’ descriptions of their pain to go by. This poor
man emerged a shell of his former self, incapable of holding down a job or
being able to take up his roles of husband and father in any normal fashion
again.
1. The infamous
“Tuskegee Study” (1932-1972) comes to mind as something as thoroughly
reprehensible as MK-ULTRA. The Alabama study identified several hundred Black
American males diagnosed with syphilis. The study’s authors did not inform them
they had contracted the disease and withheld treatment to better study the
disease’s natural process, giving men free healthcare services to disguise the
true nature of the 40-year long experiment. Dozens died or developed
debilitating ailments. Wive’s of the men were infected and children were born
with congenital syphilis. Whistleblowers in 1972 revealed the story to an
appalled public, ending the study.
2. As early as
1951 the CIA had been involved with Montreal’s McGill
University. Dr. Donald Hebb, director of psychology at the university was paid $10,000 to study "sensory
deprivation". Hebb arranged for several of his students to have their senses ‘shut
down’ (eg. Blindfolds, mittens, ear plugs, etc.). He also used repeated
messages to gauge whether his students would change their opinions on, for
example, creationism vs. secularism. It was a milder form of Dr. Cameron’s “psychic
forcing”, and the sensory deprivation lasted only one day, without using drugs,
so, there were no harmful side-effects for his students. Years later, at
the Allan Memorial Institute on MU’s campus, Dr. Cameron took up
where Dr. Hebb left off.
It should be noted that Dr. Cameron was conducting his 'research' at the Allan since 1948. "Peak" CIA funding for his project occurred in the late 1950s to 1964 when the project ended. Presumably this time period was when Dr. Cameron discovered his mojo and REALLY got busy with other people's brains.
[And finally, for our CANCON readers it also should be noted that the Canadian government (via Ministry of Health and Ministry of Defence funded Dr. Cameron's work at the Allan. Hence the inclusion of the Federal Government in the class-action lawsuit. Ed.]






